A surprising new rumor is stirring excitement and debate across Marvel fan communities. It suggests that Spider-Man: Brand New Day will feature a dramatic and violent showdown—a true Spider-Man vs. Punisher clash. At the heart of the conflict? A familiar villain—Mac Gargan, aka Scorpion.
According to insider My Time To Shine Hello, the Punisher is on a relentless mission to eliminate Scorpion. But Spider-Man steps in, determined to prevent Frank Castle from crossing that fatal line. This rumored plot point may be the spark that ignites one of the MCU’s most grounded and morally complex conflicts to date.
The Rumor: Spider-Man vs. Punisher Over Scorpion
The post on X (formerly Twitter) reads:
“The Punisher was chasing Scorpion, and Spider-Man was trying to stop him from killing his target.”
Although not officially confirmed by Marvel Studios, this scoop strongly hints at an intense ethical clash. Spider-Man has always stood for justice without bloodshed, while the Punisher operates by his own brutal code. Their opposing worldviews create a natural tension—one that could explode into full-on confrontation in Brand New Day.
Moreover, this isn’t just fan service. The concept of Spider-Man trying to stop the Punisher is deeply rooted in their comic book history, where their ideologies frequently put them at odds, despite occasionally working toward similar goals.
Michael Mando’s Role in the Spider-Man vs. Punisher Conflict
Another exciting detail is the return of Michael Mando as Mac Gargan. Last seen in Spider-Man: Homecoming, Gargan’s return offers a strong narrative bridge between earlier Spider-Man films and the street-level focus of the new one. His criminal ties and violent history make him a perfect target for the Punisher—and a perfect test for Peter Parker’s moral compass.
If this rumor holds, Scorpion’s role won’t be limited to a cameo. Instead, he may become the very reason Spider-Man and the Punisher end up at odds.
Hulk Joins the Fight? More MCU Faces in Brand New Day
In addition to this tense triangle, Brand New Day is expanding its cast with some major MCU powerhouses. Mark Ruffalo is set to return as Bruce Banner / Hulk, adding even more intrigue to the film’s ensemble. While it’s unclear how Banner fits into the plot, his presence alone raises the stakes.
Meanwhile, set footage from Glasgow shows a tank racing through the streets, chased by a fleet of police cars. Fans speculate that this action-packed scene could involve the Punisher in a high-stakes pursuit—possibly while transporting or targeting Scorpion.
Kevin Feige and Tom Holland Tease Gritty Direction
Marvel Studios President Kevin Feige has confirmed that Brand New Day will focus on street-level crime—marking a clear shift from multiversal chaos to grounded storytelling. This creative choice aligns perfectly with characters like Punisher, Daredevil, and Kingpin.
At CinemaCon 2025, Tom Holland fueled speculation with a cryptic statement:
“I know we left you with a massive cliffhanger at the end of No Way Home, so Brand New Day is a fresh start. It is exactly that. That’s all I can say.”
His words suggest a thematic reboot—not just for Peter Parker’s journey, but also for the tone of the Spider-Man franchise.
If the rumored Spider-Man vs. Punisher conflict comes to life on screen, it could become one of the MCU’s most intense character showdowns. Not only does it pit two fan favorites against each other, but it also dives deep into questions of morality, justice, and consequence.
With filming currently underway in Glasgow, Spider-Man: Brand New Day is scheduled for release in July 2026. Until then, fans can only speculate how far Peter will go to stop the Punisher—and whether doing so will cost him more than he expects.
Stay tuned for the latest updates on MCU’s upcoming projects, and subscribe to Marvel Updates’ YouTube channel.
